Money & Mission in 3-D (part 1 of 3)

Jesus famously said in Matthew 6:24,

“No one can serve two masters, for either he will hate the one and love the other, or he will be devoted to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve God and money.”

Of course Jesus is right. But, assuming God is our Master, we can’t serve Him without money either. That’s true of individuals. It’s true of churches. And it’s certainly true of church networks like Cleveland Hope!

In this first of a 3-part series of posts called Money & Mission in 3-D, I want to begin looking at the dimensions of Cleveland Hope as-is, and as-it-could-be. Our first “D” is Dollars. Now that the 2019 budget year is complete, let’s start with a look at Cleveland Hope’s financial situation moving into 2020 and beyond.

Dollars

Cleveland Hope's capacity to help resource gospel endeavors locally and elsewhere depends on the regular financial contributions of our member churches. Last year’s budget called for $90,000 in church contributions. In 2019, with church gifts ranging from $40 to $14,000, we received a total of $77,079. Falling $13k short of our target was a bummer. Here’s the breakdown. Of the $77k received, over $39k (51.4%) was given by our top five (5) giving churches. The other churches (including Bridge Church, where I pastor) combined to make up the rest.

It’s a new year, and I’m trusting the Lord for more giving to Cleveland Hope! For one, last October messengers to our annual meeting passed a larger budget for 2020. How much larger? In terms of church contributions, $14,250 larger, taking our church revenue need from $90,000 to $104,250 (a 16% increase). The deeper why is that while the financial reality of a drop in giving is impossible to deny, the reasons for it are not always obvious at first, and in our case—as I explain below—I believe can be turned around. So, how will we get there? Here are some ideas:

1. Renewed Giving. Above, when I said “the ‘other churches’ combined to make up the rest…” there’s a catch: those ‘other churches’ aren’t ALL of the other churches! You see, the $77k that came in last year came from just 43 of the 61 local churches identified with Cleveland Hope. This means 18 (almost 1/3!) of the churches in our local network gave $0 in 2019. Surely at least one of them has a $100k annual budget; if that church gave just 3% to Cleveland Hope—that’s $3,000. Let’s say two of them gave $2,000, and another three gave $1,000; we’re already at $10,000. If the other twelve churches could together come up with $3,000 ($250 each), that would make up last year’s $13,000 church contribution shortfall.

   Bridge Church’s giving was down last year for a host of reasons. I know declined giving can make it tougher on churches to support local missions. Some churches can give but don’t if they or their pastors don’t see the value of local network giving. Once upon a time associations received trickle-down Cooperative Program (CP) dollars for admin costs, director salary, outreach, etc., but those days are over for Cleveland Hope. Yes, as a North American Mission Board-designated “SEND City” Cleveland does receive NAMB dollars for church planting, but not through Cleveland Hope’s budget. Except a rare request for supplemental or matching funds from our state convention for special needs, our association budget receives $0 from outside Southern Baptist agencies.

   Many of our non-giving churches gave to Southern Baptist efforts through the CP in 2019. That’s awesome! Did they join IMB missionaries on the foreign field or send team members to join a church planter in another part of Ohio or the U.S.? Perhaps not; yet they gave! So if CP-giving logic says “We may not be able to go but we can give to global gospel work through the CP,” wouldn’t the same logic apply here in our region? A church’s outreach in its own corner of Cleveland is local missions, but we’re talking about a metro area of nearly 2 million people! Your church and mine won’t be able to directly join or benefit from every event or endeavor our network supports but other churches will, and our network can’t support those things unless churches give! Every church can give something! So step 1 to strengthening our network’s financial future is closing the participation gap in giving. From $40 to $14,000 every partner plays a part. Our goal: 100% church participation!

2. New Affiliate Churches. You probably know a pastor or church nearby that’s baptistic in doctrine—perhaps non-denominational or independent Baptist. They love the Bible, believe the gospel, and want to make disciples. (I can think of three such churches in greater Cleveland right now whose pastors all attended Southern Baptist colleges or seminaries, but they aren’t partnered with us.) Why not have lunch with that pastor and share the networking vision and philosophy of Cleveland Hope? I’d be happy to join you—I’ll even buy lunch! Bring that pastor to one of our pastor breakfasts or another event to hear what’s going on across our network. The Lord might move them from independent to a new place of interdependent gospel labor. What if we on-boarded those three churches at $500, $1,000, and $2,000 respectively this year? There’s $3,500 towards our $14,250 mission budget increase.

3. Special Offering. If you’re thinking, But our church’s 2020 budget is already set; we can’t give more this year, think again! This August we’re going to promote and invite churches to take up a special-emphasis offering (think Lottie Moon, Annie Armstrong) just for Cleveland Hope. This spring and summer I’ll be creating promotional materials, including special envelopes so your folks can continue to give through their local church as they support our broader family of churches. What if we raised a modest $10,000 in year 1? That almost puts us over the top!

4. Individual Giving. Do you suppose that across our 60 churches (made up of over 6,000 total members) there might be 20 kingdom-minded people willing to invest $20 a month in our church network on top of their church tithe? They might be pastors or laypersons, people who’ve benefited from or who just believe in N-E-T-S: Networked churches & resources, Encouraged pastors, Trained leaders, and Sent teams for the gospel’s sake in greater Cleveland. Let’s call it the “2020 Campaign” (okay, maybe not a great title!) Anyway, that’s $4,800, which would bring us to $18,300. Surplus baby!! February’s almost over, so we’re going to have to kick it into high-gear! To make it even easier, be looking for a “Donate” button to appear on our website soon!

A local Baptist association’s financial bread and butter will always be church contributions. However, we can explore additional and creative revenue streams to increase our network's capacity, and I certainly don’t have all the good ideas!

Do me a favor: take a few moments and complete the Cleveland Hope Support Questionnaire included in your weekly email. Thanks!

Dollars matter. Getting Cleveland Hope onto firm financial ground through the full participation of our member churches is important, but it’s not everything. Just because there’s an organization called Cleveland Hope doesn’t mean a church should automatically give to it. I want our network to be something that every pastor can unreservedly promote to his congregation as something of value to him and to the church. So, next week we’ll explore another “D” in our 3-part series “Money & Mission in 3-D”: Deliverables—how Cleveland Hope can add value to churches and pastors.

The LORD Accepts My Prayer

My 8 year-old daughter and some of her classmates were troubled by the recent wildfires in Australia and the threat those fires posed to wildlife (mainly koalas and kangaroos). I don’t think it ended up being sent (or even written), but part of their plan to bring about a resolution to this crisis was to write a letter to President Trump expressing their concerns in hopes that he might offer some help.

How instinctive children are to go to the highest known authority when disaster threatens. My daughter and her friends knew their parents couldn’t help, nor their teachers, not even their principal. They knew if anybody could help it was the President.

The human spirit made in the image of the divine Spirit knows intuitively that without God’s intervention, disaster is certain. That’s EVERYONE! The problem is that not everyone is as in-tune with God’s Spirit as David was. He prays in Psalm 6:8-9

“Depart from me, all you workers of evil,

for the LORD has heard the sound

of my weeping.

The LORD has heard my plea;

the LORD accepts my prayer.”

Even as born-again followers of Jesus, those devoted to the gospel and active in sharing it with others, the flesh can still lie to us, suggesting to us either that our crisis isn’t worthy of God’s intervention, or (even worse) that we don’t deserve God’s help, OR (worst of all) that God can’t be relied upon to come to our aid.

Paul reminds the Ephesians about the faulty logic of lostness when he says of the Gentiles:

“They are darkened in their understanding, alienated from the life of God because of the ignorance that is in them, due to their hardness of heart. They have become callous and have given themselves up to sensuality, greedy to practice every kind of impurity.” (Eph. 4:18-19)

He’s talking about outward behavior that flows from inner blindness. And he warns the church:

“But that is not the way you learned Christ— assuming that you have heard about him and were taught in him, as the truth is in Jesus, to put off your old self, which belongs to your former manner of life and is corrupt through deceitful desires, and to be renewed in the spirit of your minds, and to put on the new self, created after the likeness of God in true righteousness and holiness.” (Eph. 4:20-24)

Paul and David knew that dependence upon God and the outer actions that reflect it begin in the mind—begin with a renewal of the spirit of the mind. It’s a renewal that reminds us that God is interested and invested in our every need. It’s a renewal that reassures us His intervention is not based on whether we deserve it or not. And it’s a renewal that anchors us in the absolute trustworthiness of God and His good heart towards us.

Are you tempted by the flesh to doubt that God will hear and accept your prayer?

Consider that God was preparing an answer to every man’s deepest, greatest need long before ever creating man. Consider that God, in love, chose to intervene in our problems and accept our prayers before ever a problem arose or a prayer was offered. His accepting of our prayers and His intervention in our looming disaster(s) is made visible and actual in the person of Jesus Christ—the Christ David foresaw and the Christ upon whom Paul sought to focus the early church.

I don’t know your crisis in detail nor do you know mine. But as I’ve been reminded this morning I want to remind you, partners in the gospel, that on the basis of our gospel Lord, our great God hears and accepts your prayer!

As the fires of personal or ministry crises rage and the workers of evil (both human and satanic) threaten, will you pause all outer activity for a few moments today in the middle of your week to deny the temptations of the flesh to doubt? Will you pause and voice a prayer in faith—a prayer for your own need, and a prayer for God’s intervention in the needs of your co-laborers in Christ?

Be assured, brothers and sisters: on the merits of Christ, the LORD accepts your prayer!

Responding to the Gift

It’s Christmas morning. You’ve invested time, thought, energy, and money into getting the perfect gift for someone you love. The moment you’ve awaited and anticipated has come. You’re far less excited about anything you may receive than you are about the joy you know your gift is going to bring that other person—it’s just perfect! Now, imagine your loved one’s response. What if it looked like one of these?

The ‘Layaway’ response. I don’t know if layaway is still a thing or not, but it was when I was a kid. I remember me and my sister trying on winter coats in August or September when they first hit the rack at Sears—not exactly my idea of a summer afternoon well-spent! Once we made our selection, we would then carry them to the service counter, mom would fill out some paperwork, and we’d leave our new coats with the clerk. We wouldn’t see our coats again until November or so. They could only be worn after they’d been paid off little by little over a few months.

Now imagine your loved one looking at the amazing gift you’ve given, looking back at you and saying, “I love it and want it, but why don’t you hang onto it for a while. I’ll pay you back little-by-little, and when this gift is fully paid off I’ll come and pick it up.” I’m guessing that’s not exactly a response you’d be okay with.

Some folks respond to the gospel—God’s gift of Jesus and salvation—this way. This is such a nice gift, and I’ll be excited to get it one day, but just not today; it’s too costly today; I need to pay it off before I can claim it. This is an “I’m not worthy of this gift yet, but I will be, you’ll see…” mentality. It wouldn’t bode well for a happy Christmas morning in your living room. Nor will it bode well for a happy meeting with God one day!

Credit. Okay, let’s restart Christmas morning. Same gift, same joy, same anticipation, same intended recipient. But what if your loved one says: “Oh wow! I’ve always wanted and needed this; thank you!” Now we’re talking, right? But then, you notice something strange. Your loved one pulls out a calculator, and after a few minutes of head scratching, a little chin stroking, and some vigorous tabulating looks at you and says, “You know what, I’d like to take this gift home and start using it today, but I also want to prove to you that I’m worthy of it. So here’s what I’ll do: I’m going to wash your car, mow your yard, rake your leaves and shovel your driveway. Basically I’ll be at your house taking care of things for a few hours at least one day per week from now on. You’re not going to regret giving this to me. I owe you and I’m gonna show you I’m good for it!

Sometimes people respond to the gospel this way. Instead of “I’m not worthy now but will be someday,” this response says, “I AM worthy of this gift now, and to prove it I’m going to pay it off with acts of service.”

Both of these responses to your perfect gift would be utterly heart-breaking to you. Motivated by love you had that person’s joy in mind, but instead of taking your kind gesture as a free gift it is seen as a debt to be paid off either in advance of receiving it or in increments after receiving it.

No Thanks. A third horrifying, Christmas-ruining response to your perfect gift is the “No thanks” response. We could also call this the “Not for me” response in which your loved one rejects the gift outright. Just imagine the confused and insulted look on your loved one’s face and the response, “Did you put the wrong person’s name on this present? This isn’t for me. I don’t need it or want it. Maybe another family member would like it.”

Can we just agree that if any of these three exchanges happens in your living room this Christmas morning, the thrill, the joys, the hopes of having given the perfect gift will vanish…and Christmas lunch is going to be really awkward.

As Christians, we will encounter versions of all three of these responses as we faithfully share God’s gospel gift with people in our lives. Many non believers either see the gospel of forgiveness through Christ as something to be earned or paid for (thus not a gift at all), or as a gift wrongly given—a gift they neither want nor feel they need.

HOWEVER, my main concern in writing this post is for us—Christians. The Advent/Christmas season gives us not just a chance to think about baby Jesus, but a needed opportunity to see ourselves yet again as recipients and to examine the response of our hearts to God’s gift based on another year of life as a Christian. Regardless of what we say to one another or even to ourselves about God’s gift of Jesus, we need to ponder what our actions, our motives, our anxieties, etc. are saying to God about His gift? Have we labored this year from a layaway standpoint: I really want eternal life, forgiveness, wholeness in Jesus, but I just don’t feel worthy of all of it…yet; God, please be patient with me as I labor to fully pay for Your gift which I hope to receive one day! OR a credit standpoint: Watch my good works and see how worthy I am of this gift, Lord…?

If not remedied by prayer, devotion to the Word, and humble, oft-renewed submission to the reality of biblical grace in the company of other grace recipients, both the layaway and credit responses will give way to a “No thanks/Not for me” response. Satan wants us to feel unworthy of God’s gift AND he also wants us to feel worthy of it. Either way, he distorts God’s gift into a non-gift, and if we labor uncorrected—even doing great things for the Lord—the “No thanks/Not for me” response will eventually emerge as having been our posture all along just hidden under a mask of false gratitude and pretentious gestures of repayment.

Alright, let’s try this one more time. It’s Christmas morning, the gift is prepared, you hand it to your loved one. Upon opening the gift, you see that person’s mouth open slightly and hear a gentle gasp. As the crinkle of wrapping paper fades, a pregnant silence fills the room. Still looking down at the gift and holding it in one hand, the other hand rises to the slightly opened mouth. A certain (good) kind of tightness rises from your chest to your own throat. You are as fixated on your loved one as he or she is on the gift in hand. Slowly the head rises and your loved one’s eyes meet yours. Sniffles. Hard swallows. Tears (good ones). And because vocal chords would be of no use, you watch as your beloved mouths an inaudible “Thank you!” Looking down at the gift and again back at you, another mouthed phrase comes, this time in a whisper: “I love it. It’s perfect! Thank you!”

You’re going to be buying, wrapping, and giving a lot of gifts this Christmas. As badly as you want your loved ones to receive them joyously, God likewise wants you to rejoice again in His matchless, undeserved, limitlessly valuable Gift of the person of His Son and the eternal and abundant life that can only be had through Him. Let’s take time to gasp and gaze at Jesus and the grace of God that He is to us. Let’s take every opportunity to be captivated in speechless wonder and gratitude and to mouth (and mean) the words “Thank you! It’s perfect” to our heavenly Father this Christmas!

And Hezekiah Welcomed Them Gladly...

"And Hezekiah welcomed them gladly. And he showed them his treasure house, the silver, the gold, the spices, the precious oil, his whole armory, all that was found in his storehouses. There was nothing in his house or in all his realm that Hezekiah did not show them."

~Isaiah 39:2

No, he didn’t write a book of the Bible—as some occasionally tease—but Hezekiah was a king, and a pretty darn good one too. That’s really saying something when you scan the vast majority of Judahite rulers between David and Jesus, the permanent Occupant of David’s throne. What a bunch of scoundrels!

Hezekiah is a fascinating study with some important points of connection for us today. Here are a few bullets of context for the verse quoted above (see 2 Chronicles 29-32 for even more):

• At 25, Hezekiah takes power in a time of great national rebellion, decay, and danger

• He has the Levitical priests purge the Temple of its filthy idols and reinstate proper worship

• He calls all Israel to remember and celebrate the Passover rightly

• He organizes the priests for faithful & more effective service

• In the face of Jerusalem being vastly outnumbered and besieged by Assyria, a hostile northern superpower, Hezekiah cries out to God who hears and delivers him and His people from destruction and domination.

We read in 2 Chron. 31:20-21: “Thus Hezekiah did throughout all Judah, and he did what was good and right and faithful before the LORD his God. And every work that he undertook in the service of the house of God and in accordance with the law and the commandments, seeking his God, he did with all his heart, and prospered.” Certainly an impressive guy in the midst of a string of mostly awful kings!

After Hezekiah’s faithfulness in the Assyrian crisis and God’s subsequent deliverance, a personal crisis strikes: Hezekiah becomes deathly sick. Isaiah the prophet tells him to get ready to die for his time is up. Again Hezekiah prays. Again God delivers and gives him 15 more years of life.

Here’s where Hezekiah’s deepest crisis hits.

Great leadership, great faithfulness, great effectiveness, and great humility had led to great prosperity for Hezekiah’s kingdom and great notoriety for himself. News of Judah’s national deliverance and Hezekiah’s personal deliverance ripple out from Jerusalem. These kinds of things don’t just happen! People far and wide are curious and want answers. When the Babylonians send an envoy to find out how such great things could happen to such a nobody king and worthless nation, what does Hezekiah do?

We’ll get to that, but first, what does Hezekiah’s God do? After all, the LORD is the One behind all this national and personal success, right? Second Chronicles 32:31 tells us: “…in the matter of the envoys of the princes of Babylon, who had been sent to him to inquire about the sign (i.e. all the good stuff) that had been done in the land, God left him to himself, in order to test him and to know all that was in his (Hezekiah’s) heart.”

Wow.

If you’re picturing angry Moses atop the rock while Israel writhes in rebellion; if you’re picturing lustful David atop his palace roof when his men are out fighting; if you’re picturing hiding, despairing Elijah complaining to God that he’s the only faithful one left in Israel; or if you’re picturing boastful Peter declaring his readiness to die with Jesus in front of the other disciples, you’re on the right track towards understanding Hezekiah’s plight: he’s been faithful to God, used of God; he’s said right things, done right things, and experienced visible signs of God’s favor and blessing; but he has a blind spot: his own heart. God isn’t blind to Hezekiah’s, Moses’, David’s, Peter’s, or our blind spots … but they were, and we can be too! The moment we feel the glow of success however big or small, especially having faced crises with faith, having followed God through hard stuff, having attained a moral and experiential footing from which to ascribe credit for the success, that is the most dangerous moment of all for a child of God.

How easy it is to look at visible successes and to overlook the invisible God who made them possible, even when we’ve acknowledged Him openly in the past, before or during a crisis. How easy it is to unlock the storehouse doors, to open the lids on the treasure chests of our lives and point curious outsiders to beautiful, tangible blessings when it is only God who has granted them.

Moses had encountered God face-to-face; he’d prayed for God to spare rebellious Israel in the past, and he felt he ought to get to strike the rock like before when this time God specifically said to speak to the rock in order to provide Israel with water. David stood for God’s honor when Goliath blasphemed, refused to kill Saul when his own men urged him to do so, and defended Israel valiantly time and time again. Surely these successes afforded him a one-nighter with another man’s wife? Elijah called down fire and slew 400 false prophets. Isn’t that worth a little self-congratulatory wound-licking? Peter nailed the answer to Jesus’ question: “Who do you say I am?” But even here Jesus reminds him and the other disciples that “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God” came from the Father, not Peter.

“In those days Hezekiah became sick and was at the point of death, and he prayed to the LORD, and He answered him and gave him a sign. But Hezekiah did not make return according to the benefit done to him, for his heart was proud.” (2 Chron. 32:24-25)

God does nothing for us that He doesn’t expect us to fully credit or praise Him for doing. Hezekiah showcased God’s bountiful blessings for the Babylonian inquirers, but failed to showcase God. 2 Chron. 32:26a tells us that“Hezekiah humbled himself for the pride of his heart, both he and the inhabitants of Jerusalem so that the wrath of the LORD did not come upon them in the days of Hezekiah.” That’s good, right? Sure, for Hezekiah and his generation, but it wasn’t good for the coming generation! Hezekiah dies and the next chapter opens: “Manasseh was twelve years old when he began to reign, and he reigned fifty five years in Jerusalem. And he did what was evil in the sight of the LORD…”

What if while visiting all the grain storehouses and treasuries with his father the boy Manasseh had heard his dad give God worship before the Babylonians rather than showing off all of his wealth? One generation’s prideful failure to fully credit God became the next generation’s utter abandonment of God.

I want you to experience success. I want you to face adversity and crises of all kinds with faith and to taste the blessings and favor of God in real and tangible ways on the other side. I want curious outsiders and onlookers to investigate the visible goodness of God in your life. I want your church to weather its present crisis under your faithful, prayerful leadership and to emerge into a new season of revival and growth such that other pastors and even non-believers notice. I want the strife in your marriage or other strained family relationships to be the occasion for personal, spiritual deepening and dependance on God such that true healing and reconciliation not only happens but gets the attention of others. I want you to know the healing touch of God on your physical body, your emotions: your depression, your anxiety, etc. I want these and other kinds of “successes” for myself too! But what I want most of all is to avoid the temptation to showcase the tangible marks of blessing to the neglect of the Blesser. What I want most is for us to not fail to “make return according to the benefit done to us” by our great and gracious God.

We won’t fail in this if our pride is in check. We do this by keeping close to God’s word and to God in prayer, not just when the heat of pressure and crisis is bearing down and threatening to crush us but also (perhaps especially) when the pressure and crisis subsides. Then, when the curious come wanting to know why, what, and how, like Hezekiah, we can still welcome them gladly, but without failing to identify the right Who that has brought us through and blessed us!

Others More Significant

When the default mode of the flesh is "me first, me most, me best, ..." it takes incredible focus and discipline to set aside selfish ambition and humbly count others more significant than ourselves. The Philippians 2:3 life can't start from the body; it has to start in the mind. And it won't start in our minds on its own; that's why Paul tells the Philippians in v. 5 to have the mind of Christ.

The most important word in Phil. 2:3 is hegemenoi ("to count," to "consider," to "think," to "have the opinion," etc. in English). If the individual Christian is to count, consider, or esteem others as more important than him or herself, is it reasonable to assume that the Philippians 2:3 principle applies at the church-to-church level as well? I have to believe so! I have to believe it's right, good, and proper for each church to live out Philippians 2:3 in relation to other churches.

What might this look like?

Don't get me wrong, I appreciate every church's undesignated gift to Cleveland Hope whether large or small. This enables us to collectively meet needs across our network from a central fund. Please don't stop giving to your association!! But can a church make Philippians 2:3 a more hands-on, direct, and targeted mindset and lifestyle? As you prepare mission budgets for 2020 (i.e., what you’ll invest in the Kingdom beyond your church), consider setting aside a few hundred or even a few thousand dollars for the purpose of blessing a specific neighboring church and/or pastor or two. Would you consider reaching out to a couple of churches or pastors whom your church could serve in such a way that your church receives no tangible or material benefit but only the intangible blessing of knowing you invested in the Kingdom next door, next town, next ward, next zip code over? What's that neighboring church got in the way of obstacles that your church doesn't have (or does have but to a lesser degree)? Can you help them purchase a van because they're reaching folks who can't afford cars? Can you help them with some money and manpower to patch a leaky roof or refurbish a church bathroom? What's that neighboring church got in terms of opportunities that your church doesn't have but that your church could help them seize with some periodic volunteers or bucks?

This is how a net works. A fish may not swim into every square of a net at once (unless it's a really big fish!), but that part of the net depends on all the other links (especially those closest to it) to lend it strength so that the catch isn't lost. It's radical (downright unfathomable to many) in our competitive culture to consider others more significant than oneself. Sadly, a church can become so convinced it's at the epicenter of God's global mission that it can actually miss the mind of Christ, which always sacrifices self to bless others.

What will your church do in 2020 to rock the Philippians 2:3 principle?